316Ti Stainless Steel 904L vs 316Ti Guide
Published: November 11, 2025 | Updated: November 11, 2025By Gangsteel Engineering Team – 25+ Years in Stainless Steel Export Excellence
In the competitive landscape of stainless steels compliant with ASTM A240/A240M and ASME SA240/SA240M standards, comparing 904L (super-austenitic) and 316Ti (titanium-stabilized austenitic) reveals fundamental differences in corrosion resistance, mechanical properties, and suitability for severe environments.
As a premier producer and exporter based in China, Gangsteel has supplied thousands of tons of both 904L and 316Ti stainless steel, meeting ASTM A240/A240M specs for plates and sheets, to industries such as petrochemical, marine, and pharmaceutical.
If you're evaluating 904L vs 316Ti under ASME SA240/SA240M for a chemical reactor or seawater piping where pitting, acid resistance, or high-temp durability is critical, this guide provides a clear, data-driven comparison. We'll break down their attributes, including corrosion, mechanicals, and more, based on ASTM A240/A240M and ASME SA240/SA240M standards and our mill data.
From our production lines, we've seen the performance difference: In a 2024 Singapore chemical plant, our 904L piping under ASTM A240 /A240M resisted concentrated sulfuric acid at 80°C with rates <0.01 mm/year, outperforming 316Ti (0.05 mm/year) by 80% in pitting tests. Compliant with ASME SA240/SA240M for pressure apps, 904L's PREN 36-43 vs 316Ti's 23-28 supports ultra-corrosive use. Let's delve into the comparison, from composition to applications, to guide your choice.
Summary
904L and 316Ti stainless steel under ASTM A240/A240M and ASME SA240/SA240M both offer strong corrosion resistance, but 904L's higher alloying (Mo 4-5%, Ni 23-28%, Cu 1-2%) provides superior pitting and acid resistance (PREN 36-43 vs 23-28 for 316Ti), making it ideal for severe corrosives like sulfuric acid or seawater. 316Ti, with titanium stabilization, excels in high-temp IGC resistance (425-815°C) and is 30-50% cheaper ($3,200-3,800/ton vs $5,000-6,000 for 904L FOB China 2025). Strength is comparable (tensile 515 MPa for 316Ti, 490 for 904L), but 904L has better SCC durability. Density ~8.00 g/cm³ for both. Choose 904L for extreme acids, 316Ti for heat-corrosives. Gangsteel stocks both with certs for custom needs.
Chemical Composition: The Alloying Edge
The compositions of 904L and 316Ti, as per ASTM A240/A240M and ASME SA240/SA240M, underscore 904L's superior acid resistance.
|
Element |
316Ti % |
904L % |
Key Difference Impact |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Carbon (C) |
0.08 max |
0.02 max |
Lower in 904L for better resistance; 316Ti's Ti binds it. |
|
Manganese (Mn) |
2.00 max |
2.00 max |
Identical. |
|
Silicon (Si) |
0.75 max |
1.00 max |
904L higher for oxidation. |
|
Phosphorus (P) |
0.045 max |
0.045 max |
Identical. |
|
Sulfur (S) |
0.030 max |
0.035 max |
Low for both. |
|
Chromium (Cr) |
16.00-18.00 |
19.00-23.00 |
Higher in 904L for superior passivation. |
|
Molybdenum (Mo) |
2.00-3.00 |
4.00-5.00 |
904L's higher Mo boosts pitting (PREN 36-43 vs. 23-28). |
|
Nickel (Ni) |
10.00-14.00 |
23.00-28.00 |
Much higher in 904L for acid resistance. |
|
Copper (Cu) |
- |
1.00-2.00 |
Cu in 904L enhances sulfuric acid resistance. |
|
Titanium (Ti) |
5x(C+N) min, 0.70 max |
- |
Ti in 316Ti prevents IGC at high temps. |
|
Nitrogen (N) |
0.10 max |
0.10 max |
Identical. |
|
Iron (Fe) |
Balance |
Balance |
Base matrix. |
904L's high Mo/Ni/Cu give it an edge in acids, while 316Ti's Ti focuses on high-temp IGC.
Mechanical Properties: Comparable with Edges
Both grades have similar room-temp properties, but 904L's higher alloys improve durability under stress.
|
Property |
316Ti Min |
904L Min |
Key Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Tensile Strength (MPa) |
515 |
490 |
Similar; 904L retains better in acids. |
|
Yield Strength (MPa) |
205 |
220 |
904L slightly higher for load durability. |
|
Elongation (%) |
40 |
35 |
316Ti more ductile for forming. |
|
Hardness (HRB max) |
95 |
90 |
Both soft; 904L harder in work. |
|
Impact Toughness (J) |
~100 at RT |
~150 at RT |
904L better for impacts. |
Both durable, but 904L's composition enhances SCC resistance.
Physical Properties: Comparable with Acid Edge for 904L
Both have similar physicals, but 904L's alloys improve acid durability.
|
Property |
316Ti Value |
904L Value |
Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Density (g/cm³) |
8.00 |
8.00 |
Identical. |
|
Thermal Conductivity (W/m·K at 100°C) |
14.6 |
12.9 |
316Ti better heat transfer. |
|
Specific Heat (J/kg·K) |
500 |
500 |
Identical. |
|
Thermal Expansion (10^-6 /°C, 20-100°C) |
16.5 |
15.8 |
904L lower for stability. |
904L more resistant to thermal stress corrosion.
Corrosion Resistance: 904L's Dominance in Severe Conditions
904L outclasses 316Ti in most corrosives due to higher alloys.
- Pitting/Crevice: 904L PREN 36-43 vs. 23-28; CPT ~45-55°C vs. 25°C.
- IGC: Both resistant (316Ti Ti-stabilized, 904L low C).
- SCC: 904L better in chlorides/acids.
- Uniform: 904L <0.01 mm/year in strong acids; both good but 904L in harsher.
- High-Temp: 316Ti better for IGC at 425-815°C; 904L for general acid heat.
904L more corrosion-durable overall.
Weldability and Fabrication: Similar Ease
Both weld well; 316Ti's Ti eliminates annealing, 904L's high alloys require care to avoid hot cracking. Machinability ~60% for both.
Gangsteel's 316Ti SA240 Type 316Ti offers simpler fab.
Applications: Overlapping but Specialized
- Common: Chemical equipment (both durable).
- 904L Specific: Pulp/paper (acid resistance).
- 316Ti Specific: High-temp processing (IGC protection).
In Gangsteel's supply to U.S. chemical, 904L lasted longer in H2SO4.
Cost Comparison: 904L's Premium for Performance
In 2025, 904L costs 30-50% more than 316Ti ($5,000-6,000/ton vs $3,200-3,800 FOB China) due to Ni/Mo/Cu, but saves on maintenance in severe corrosives.
Equivalents: Alternatives for Both
316Ti equivalents: EN 1.4571. 904L equivalents: EN 1.4539. For A240 GR 316Ti, not interchangeable with 904L in acid-heavy apps.
Sourcing from Gangsteel: Stock and Pricing
Gangsteel stocks 316Ti and 904L at $3,200-3,800/ton (316Ti) and $5,000-6,000 (904L) FOB. 1-200mm thick, certs. Contact for comparisons.
FAQ: 316Ti vs 904L Performance Questions Answered
Q: How does corrosion resistance compare between 316Ti and 904L stainless steel?A: 904L has superior corrosion resistance in acidic environments like sulfuric acid due to higher Mo (4-5%) and Cu (1-2%), with PREN 36-43 vs. 23-28 for 316Ti.
Q: What are the mechanical property differences between 316Ti and 904L?A: Both have similar tensile (515 MPa for 316Ti, 490 for 904L) and elongation (40% vs. 35%), but 904L's yield is slightly higher (220 vs. 205 MPa), with better SCC performance.
Q: Is 904L better than 316Ti for marine applications?A: Yes, 904L's higher PREN (36.7 avg) offers better resistance to chloride pitting in ocean environments than 316Ti (PREN ~25), though 316Ti suffices for moderate marine use.
Q: How does high-temperature performance compare for 316Ti and 904L?A: 316Ti excels in high-temp IGC resistance (425-815°C) due to Ti, while 904L is better for general oxidation and acid heat but lacks Ti for sensitization prevention.
Q: What is the cost difference between 316Ti and 904L in 2025?A: 904L is 30-50% more expensive ($5,000-6,000/ton vs $3,200-3,800 for 316Ti FOB China) due to higher Ni/Mo/Cu, but 316Ti offers value in high-temp apps.
Q: Can I substitute 904L for 316Ti?A: Yes for upgraded acid resistance, but 904L costs more and has different properties; 316Ti for high-temp IGC focus.
Q: How does 316Ti vs 904L compare in nitric acid corrosion?A: 904L has less resistance in aggressive nitric acid than molybdenum-free grades like 304L, while 316Ti performs well in dilute nitric but not as specialized.
-
BHW35 Steel Plate for Sale | RF
BHW35 / 13MnNiMo5-4 (DIWA 353 family): identity, chemistry, mechanical properties, related grades, and RFQ note
-
ASTM A516 Grade 70 Equivalent:
ASTM A516 Grade 70 equivalents include ASME SA516 Gr 70, EN 10028-2 P355GH and BS 1501 224-490. Gangsteel compa
-
What is the difference between
we supply high-quality A516 Gr 70 steel plate for pressure vessel applications and other standards like ASTM A2
-
P355GH AND S355J2 Steel Plates
EN10028-2 P355GH for High-Strength Low-Alloy Columbium-Vanadium Structural Steel EN10025-2 S355J2 Structural St
