Difference Between SA 537 Class 1 and Class 2

What is the Difference Between SA 537 Class 1 and Class 2?

In the specialized field of pressure vessel and boiler manufacturing, understanding the nuances between material grades like SA 537 Class 1 and Class 2 is essential for selecting the right steel to meet specific engineering requirements.

At Gangsteel, we specialize in producing and exporting high-quality plates under the ASME SA537/SA537M standard, including ASME SA 537 Class 1 and ASME SA 537 Class 2.

SA 537 (ASME SA537) is a heat-treated carbon-manganese-silicon steel for welded pressure vessels, with Class 1 being normalized for moderate strength and Class 2 quenched and tempered for higher strength.

Class 2 offers enhanced tensile and yield properties, making it suitable for more demanding applications.

This guide from Gangsteel compares the two classes, focusing on heat treatment, composition, properties, and applications.

For other options, explore our ASME SA537 Cl.1 or ASME SA 537 Class 3.

Key Differences in Overview

The main distinction between SA 537 Class 1 and Class 2 lies in heat treatment and resulting mechanical performance.

Class 1 is normalized (heated to ~900°C and air-cooled) for uniform toughness in standard services.

Class 2 is quenched (rapidly cooled in water/oil) and tempered for higher strength and hardness in high-pressure or low-temperature environments.

Class 2 allows thinner plates, reducing material costs, but may need stricter welding controls.

Both are used in oil/gas and petrochemicals, but Class 2 excels in sour service.

Gangsteel recommends Class 2 for tougher conditions.

Chemical Composition Comparison

Both classes share identical compositions, with differences stemming from heat treatment effects.

In asme sa537 class 1 boiler steel chemical composition details and Class 2, low carbon ensures weldability, manganese provides strength, and silicon aids deoxidation.

Low phosphorus/sulfur (0.035% max) prevents brittleness.

Optional alloys like copper enhance corrosion resistance.

Composition table (common to both):

No chemical differences; performance varies due to treatment.

Mechanical Properties Comparison

Mechanical differences are significant due to heat treatment.

Class 1: Yield 50 ksi (345 MPa) min ≤65mm, tensile 70-90 ksi (485-620 MPa).

Class 2: Yield 60 ksi (415 MPa) min ≤65mm, tensile 80-100 ksi (550-690 MPa).

Class 2 has higher values for demanding loads.

Properties table (≤65mm thick):

Class 2 suits high-pressure, Class 1 moderate.

Heat Treatment and Applications

Class 1 is normalized for all thicknesses, providing uniform properties for standard boilers.

Class 2 is quenched and tempered, enhancing strength for high-pressure or low-temperature vessels.

Class 1 for general moderate-temp tanks; Class 2 for sour gas reactors with better HIC resistance.

Gangsteel advises Class 2 for low-temp toughness.

Equivalent Materials for SA 537

SA 537 equivalents are ASTM A537, with Class 1 like EN P355GH, Class 2 like EN P460NH.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About the Difference Between SA 537 Class 1 and Class 2

What is the difference between SA 537 Class 1 and Class 2?

SA 537 Class 1 is normalized with yield 50 ksi min, suitable for standard services, while Class 2 is quenched and tempered with higher yield 60 ksi min for high-pressure or low-temp applications.

What is the heat treatment difference?

Class 1: Normalized (air-cooled from 900°C); Class 2: Quenched (water/oil-cooled) and tempered for finer grain and higher strength.

What is the mechanical properties difference?

Class 1: Yield 50 ksi, tensile 70-90 ksi; Class 2: Yield 60 ksi, tensile 80-100 ksi, allowing thinner plates in Class 2.

What is the application difference?

Class 1 for moderate-pressure boilers; Class 2 for high-pressure or sour gas vessels with better toughness.

In summary, SA 537 Class 1 and Class 2 differ in heat treatment and strength, with Class 2 for tougher conditions. Contact Gangsteel for supply.

asme sa537 class 1 vs class 2 comparison, sa 537 class 1 chemical composition details, sa 537 class 2 yield strength specifications